Coop Exhibit Y

Date: Fri, 09 Nov 2001 16:04:08 -0700
To: "Corbetta, Richard" <Richard.Corbetta@qwest.com>
From: Carl Oppedahl <carl@oppedahl.com>
Subject: Re: Ruby Ranch Coop
Cc: "McKenney, Audrey" <axmcken@qwest.com>, "Donahue, Nancy" <ndonahu@qwest.com>
, "Fleming, Kathy" <kflemin@qwest.com>

At 03:24 PM 11/9/2001, Corbetta, Richard wrote:

>Mr. Oppedahl:

>Audrey Mckenney asked that I provide a brief response to your email message
>sent on November 7, 2001.  Qwest has worked diligently to accommodate the
>needs of Ruby Ranch Coop.  We continue to do so.  

I am most grateful if Qwest henceforth works diligently to accommodate our needs.  
Let's schedule a negotiation telephone conference in which:

a.  Qwest will provide pricing information to support its $1707 quote 
preparation fee;

b.  Qwest will provide pricing information to support its $126 non-recurring 
fee for installation of a subloop;

c.  Qwest will explain in appropriate technical detail what risks the Coops 
activities present to the Qwest network that somehow exceed the risks 
presented by POTS and LADS customers.